The Riddle of St. Leonard's by Candace Robb.
This is the 5th mystery in the Owen Archer series by Candace Robb. The year is 1369, and the story is set during the third bout of plague in the rule of King Edward. Archer is a one-eyed former archer, who now works as a spy for the Archbishop of York. The Bishop's nephew, Sir Richard de Ravenser, is Master of the Hospital at St. Leonard's. The hospital is facing a host of problems - someone is murdering "corrodians" (the elderly boarders of the institution), a series of thefts have been perpetrated at the hospital, and the hospital now faces financial ruin. In the midst of the plague in the city, Archer is 'borrowed' by Sir Richard from the Archbishop to investigate the murders and thefts in York.
I gave this one a try after being gifted it. I love Ellis Peters' Brother Cadfael series of books, set in the 1100s during the civil war between Stephen and Maud, and this looked like another series of fun historical mysteries. And, to a certain extent, it was.
I gave this one a try after being gifted it. I love Ellis Peters' Brother Cadfael series of books, set in the 1100s during the civil war between Stephen and Maud, and this looked like another series of fun historical mysteries. And, to a certain extent, it was.
I honestly have very mixed feelings about this one. I wanted to really like it, I really did! I just really didn't like any of the characters in the book! Granted, I did start with book 5 in the series, but I was gifted it and couldn't find books 1-4 in our tiny post library, so I had to start somewhere :) By book 5 in a series, you already know the characters, and care about them, and there doesn't have to be as much time spent developing them. And I dropped into the middle of that, so I do take that into account. However, the fact remains that the most developed character in the book was a thoroughly unlikable child (and she was described that way by the author too!!). The detective characters, Archer and his family and friends, almost seemed like side notes, characters that things happen to, rather than the strong protagonists I've enjoyed in other works.
Thinking about it, I think the most developed 'character' was the plague itself. The plague permeated every aspect, every scene of the book, as I imagine the actual plague dominated daily life at that time. The novel is very rich in historical detail, describing life in the hospital, in the town (York, a place I LOVE) and the turmoil that the plague threw daily life. It was a very interesting read, a very rich historical novel. Not quite one that I voraciously read, but one I was eagerly picking up each night.
If you're looking for a good mystery, however, I'd suggest another book. There really wasn't that much of a puzzle in this one. Because so few characters were introduced, it was very easy to figure out who the culprit was. You might not know why they were doing all they were doing, but you certainly knew who was up to no good.
Overall: 3 out of 5. I'm glad I read it, and I'll probably read the rest of the series too, but it'll be from the library, and not on my own bookshelf.
Thinking about it, I think the most developed 'character' was the plague itself. The plague permeated every aspect, every scene of the book, as I imagine the actual plague dominated daily life at that time. The novel is very rich in historical detail, describing life in the hospital, in the town (York, a place I LOVE) and the turmoil that the plague threw daily life. It was a very interesting read, a very rich historical novel. Not quite one that I voraciously read, but one I was eagerly picking up each night.
If you're looking for a good mystery, however, I'd suggest another book. There really wasn't that much of a puzzle in this one. Because so few characters were introduced, it was very easy to figure out who the culprit was. You might not know why they were doing all they were doing, but you certainly knew who was up to no good.
Overall: 3 out of 5. I'm glad I read it, and I'll probably read the rest of the series too, but it'll be from the library, and not on my own bookshelf.
