One of my resolutions this year is trying to read more. My goal is 2 books a month, and so far, that's a pretty good average pace. Average, because I never read one book at a time, so it's not always an even 2-a-month. For example, I didn't really finish much in June, because I had 4 books going, so I'm on pace to make up for that in July :)
This one was one that was a free download on Amazon Kindle (click the picture below to go to the Amazon page): Pride, Prejudice, and Cheese Grits by Mary Jane Hathaway.

Shelby Roswell is a history professor on the fast track to tenure until
her new book is crushed in a review by the famous historian, Ransom
Fielding. She struggles to regain her momentum only to discover that
Fielding has taken a visiting professorship at her college. The place
that was once a refuge from the poverty of her past is now a battlefield
of Civil War proportions.
Ransom is still struggling with his role
in his wife’s accidental death six years ago and was hoping a year at
Shelby’s small college would be a respite from the reminders back home.
He never bargained for falling in love with the one woman who would give
anything to make him leave. Together Shelby and Ransom learn that home
is never very far away, and when you least expect it, love arrives.
With
a cast of Civil War re-enactors, an evil wedding planner, antebellum
mansions, and several mysterious diaries, 'Pride, Prejudice and Cheese
Grits' will take you on a touching and hilarious ride through a modern
South you haven't seen before. NOW WITH RECIPES
Yes, I got the one with the recipes too. The only appearance of the cheese grits, as a matter of fact (they don't play any part in the story).
Free Kindle books are nice, but I'm still not going to waste my time, even if I haven't wasted money, on a book that's not worth it. So, I always start with the other Amazon user comments, just to get an idea if it might be interesting. Beyond that, I read it to make up my mind on my own :)
One of most frequent complaints in the the Amazon reviews questioned the Pride and Prejudice connections. It honestly didn't bother me too much. Hot-headed heroine, awkward hero, lots of butting heads and misconceptions. At that level, it really didn't bother me. There were scenes that were straight out of P&P, though. Funnily enough, those were the scenes I liked the least. Just didn't fit, somehow. (Slight spoiler alert) The party that Shelby goes to with her mom and sisters and the disastrous matchmaking attempt was straight-up Mr. Collins. And that honestly bothered me. It's a modern story, but that scene just seemed so... anachronistic. I mean, I have friends who have received "You're not getting any younger" type comments from friends or family, but in this day and age, 27 is not absurd, especially for someone in academia. PhDs aren't overnight degrees, after all. Her mother getting frantic about her 27-year-old daughter turning down a date with a guy in his early 40s just seemed out of place. Yes, Shelby did behave on the ruder side, but the guy was pretty much insulting everything she'd worked for and cared about.
The other big complaint in the Amazon reviews were about proofreading mistakes. Looks like I downloaded a later edition, because it wasn't an issue. There were still some, and a few continuity things that nagged at me, but otherwise, don't be put off by that criticism.
As for the story itself...
It is Christian romance. Meaning, no steamy scenes. Lots of banter, smoldering looks, and a kiss or two before the wedding at the end. It is listed as Religious Romance in the categories down near bottom of the Amazon page. I hadn't really noticed it, but I'm up for Austen in any form. If you're not, or you're looking for something steamier, this isn't the book for that.
On that same note, it's not a beat-you-over-the-head preaching sort of story. A character is looking for forgiveness, another for strength, characters pray and from time to time, talk about the importance of faith in a relationship. And that's about it. No moralizing, not really heavy handed proselytizing. I didn't find it distracting from the story at all.
I liked the lead characters. Shelby, the heroine, is outspoken, honest, pretty but not "everybody hates me because I'm too pretty" (yes, I recently tried to start one whose heroine was like that. I couldn't finish it). And yes, I have a partiality for nerdy, sarcastic, curly redheads :) The hero, Ransom, is suitably awkward and proud for an Austen hero. I liked them, honestly. I powered through the book in 2 days, so it kept my attention pretty securely.
I liked the best friend as a character, too. A lot of the other secondary characters seemed very underdeveloped, though. They just kinda appeared for a scene and then disappeared. Tasha, the romantic rival, was entertaining, if aggravating, but then my personality tends more to Shelby's views than Tasha's.
I felt the disasters were a little rushed, especially at the end. The video especially seemed to just come and go with little development. Things just kinda happened and then never mentioned again, like the author was trying to fit in too much. Like the faux pas at Ransom's aunt's party? And the back-to-back disasters towards the end felt very rushed. Everything worked out alright, and for the most part, no loose ends. Just felt like things kinda happened and then were gone, no lasting repercussions.
My biggest complaint was the questionable Southern geography. The book is set at the fictitious Midland College in the fictitious town of Spartainville, MS. So, they talk about going to Oxford for shopping and so forth. No problem, there's an Oxford, MS. The heroine's hometown is Flea Bite Creek, though. Though it's never mentioned where Flea Bite Creek is in the book, there really IS a Flea Bite Creek. In South Carolina. South of Columbia, actually, about 9 hours from Oxford, MS. Resulted in a few issues for me:
- Her "regular weekends home" seemed off to me. I've done the 8 hr drive from Greenville, SC to Virginia Beach, VA very regularly, and it's makes for a very draining weekend. Add two more hours for the round trip... Hard to believe.
- With the 9 hr distance, the dismissive way people talked about Flea Bite Creek just didn't fit. If you're going to be dismissive about a tiny Southern town, you're going to do so about the ones nearby, not ones 9 hours away. People always talk about what they know.
- Also, characters mentioned Savannah and Charleston as destinations like they were just a couple hours away. From Oxford, MS, these cities are each about 10 hours away. People tend to be 'out of sight, out of mind' so seemed a little weird. It's like being in Atlanta and regularly talking about Baltimore as a destination. The Southeast uses a relatively small radius, as a region; things are more compact. I've learned in Texas, an hour and a half drive is nothing. "Oh, it's just in Austin." In the Southeast, that same hour and a half would pass a dozen more towns than what would be in the same stretch in Texas or further west.
I realize it's a stupid complaint for a work of fiction, but I spent
two years looking at Southern maps for my job, including for some job sites in
Oxford, and it bothered me. It was as if the South was just a nebulous region in this story, everything all kinda near each other. Probably not something that would bother too many other people, but there you go. One of those little tickles in the back of your mind in the story that wouldn't go away.
Overall: 3.75 of 5. Glad it was a free book, but I'm always glad of a free book. I don't know if I'd've bought it, but it was pretty good and it did draw me in. It's a Christian romance, as mentioned, so nothing steamy, but the characters are cute together. Likable leads, and in all, a nice, fluffy, fun read. Just some quirks that made me wonder if the author had spent much time in the South...