One that Zach chose from Netflix Instant Watch. He was pretty surprised I hadn't seen it yet. This time: Fargo.

Plot: Jerry Lundegaard works in his father-in-law's car dealership and has gotten himself in financial problems (what they are, we never really know). He tries various schemes to come up with money, but when all else fails, he plans for two men to kidnap his wife. He plans for ransom to be paid by her wealthy father (who doesn't seem to have the time of day for Jerry). The ransom will be split between Jerry and the kidnappers. No one hurt, no one the wiser. At least, that's the plan, but what happens is something totally different. Jerry, who is not the brightest of individuals, has hired a pair of bigger losers than himself. From the moment of the kidnapping, things go wrong and what was supposed to be a non-violent affair turns bloody with more blood added by the minute. Jerry is upset at the bloodshed, and that it has brought the attentions of Marge Gunderson, a pregnant sheriff from Brainerd, MN. As Marge investigates, Jerry's plans continue to unravel...
Oh, the whole plan is hatched in Fargo, ND. Hence the title.
A dark comedy, that yes, I, too, am surprised I haven't seen yet!
Played very seriously (it's even presented as a true story at the start of the movie). Which is always a strong point with a dark comedy - horrible, subtly funny events played seriously. Yeah, I like a good dark comedy. The thick Minnesota accents just make it better. Because, let's face it, it is a funny accent (well, like a lot of accents when they're that thick). How can you not grin at someone who's asking questions about a murder, and peppering it with "Don'tcha know?"s and "You betcha!"s?
The acting, accents aside, was very well done. I considered it a very good sign for the movie when the first three characters we are introduced to are played by William H. Macy, Steve Buscemi, and Peter Stormare, all three good actors. Frances McDormand (who played Marge, the pregnant Chief investigating crimes) earned an Oscar for Best Actress, and William H. Macy was nominated for Best Supporting Actor. Both very strong performances. Really - how many actresses can deliver a line like "Oh for Pete's sake, he's fleeing the interview! He's fleeing the interview!" and make it as serious and as funny as she did? It's just impossible to improve on that delivery of it. She's so serious and straightforward dealing with all craziness happening around her - makes for a very entertaining character.
The music and cinematography are both really well done too. Both really work to keep the movie serious, even as funny as the events' chaotic happenings are. It is still the story of kidnapping, robbery, and 7 murders after all! The quiet classical pieces work so well with the serious moments, just beautifully. And the filming of the North Dakota/Minnesota area in winter gives the piece a nice somber background against which all this insanity and bloodshed plays out. Cinematography was another Oscar nomination, FYI :)
But it's the writing that is so subtly funny. Definitely earned the Oscar for writing! These characters are just so, so awkward!
"What'd this guy look like anyway?"
"Oh, he was a little guy, kinda funny lookin'."
"Uh-huh. In what way?"
"Just a general way."
Really, how else would you describe Steve Buscemi? And of course you can't forget the wood-chipper scene!
Overall: 5 of 5. A very funny, dark comedy. Certainly shelf-worthy. "You're darned tootin'!"